Lumen
RS
LAYER 3 · REPORT

Self-Assessment

The filing artifact: a self-assessment against the 13 CCPA dark patterns plus a remediation plan with owners and timelines - generated from live scanner and provenance data.

Dark Patterns Compliance - Self-Assessment & Remediation Plan
Assessed against the CCPA Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023
Ref: LUMEN/SA/2026-27/014
Assessment date: 20 Jun 2026
Prepared by: Lumen Compliance Workspace

1Executive summary

Compliance score
15/100
Patterns present
13/13
Sub-rules hit
15/29
Open findings
21
Critical
10

A scan of 10 regulated digital surfaces (web, app, aggregator and WhatsApp) across motor and health lines identified 21 open findings spanning 13 of the 13 statutory dark patterns. The most material risks are pre-ticked add-ons (interface interference), tax-exclusive headline pricing (drip pricing) and unconsented checkout injections (basket sneaking). A remediation plan with owners and target dates is at §4. Going forward, consent for every sale is captured in a tamper-evident provenance ledger (§5) to evidence informed consent on demand.

2Scope of assessment

Motor - Quote & Add-ons · webMotor - Checkout & Payment · webHealth - Plan & Riders · appHealth - Checkout & Payment · appLife - Term Quote & Riders · appLife - Proposal & Payment · webLife - Surrender & Free-look · webAggregator - Best Plans Ranking · aggregatorRenewal Reminder Journey · whatsappCancellation & Free-look · web

3Self-assessment against the 13 dark patterns

CodePatternPresentFindingsMax severity
DP-01False UrgencyYes1High
DP-02Basket SneakingYes3Critical
DP-03Confirm ShamingYes3High
DP-04Forced ActionYes1Medium
DP-05Subscription TrapYes2Critical
DP-06Interface InterferenceYes4Critical
DP-07Bait and SwitchYes1High
DP-08Drip PricingYes3Critical
DP-09Disguised AdvertisementYes1High
DP-10NaggingYes1Medium
DP-11Trick QuestionYes1Low
DP-12SaaS BillingYes1Medium
DP-13Rogue Malware / ScarewareYes1High

4Remediation plan

F-101Interface InterferenceItem 6(a)Motor - Quote & Add-onsCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Over-highlighting certain information· PARK
Action: Default all optional covers to unchecked; require explicit per-cover opt-in.
Owner: Motor Digital - Pod A·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-102Drip PricingItem 8(i)Motor - Quote & Add-onsCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Price elements not revealed upfront / revealed surreptitiously· BLOCK
Action: Show all-inclusive payable (premium + 18% GST + selected add-ons) on the first quote card.
Owner: Motor Digital - Pod A·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-105Basket SneakingItem 2 (chapeau)Motor - Checkout & PaymentCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Adding unconsented items/charges at checkout· BLOCK
Action: Block any line item lacking a logged customer opt-in from entering the payable.
Owner: Motor Digital - Pod A·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-201Interface InterferenceItem 6(a)Health - Plan & RidersCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Over-highlighting certain information· PARK
Action: Default riders unchecked; surface each with plain-language benefit + cost.
Owner: Health Digital - Pod C·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-202Interface InterferenceItem 6(b)Health - Plan & RidersCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Obscuring other relevant information· PARK
Action: Promote material exclusions (waiting periods, co-pay, sub-limits) to the plan card with equal prominence.
Owner: Health Digital - Pod C·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-204Basket SneakingItem 2 (chapeau)Health - Checkout & PaymentCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Adding unconsented items/charges at checkout· BLOCK
Action: Remove auto-injected items; strict opt-in with disclosed renewal terms.
Owner: Health Digital - Pod C·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-501Interface InterferenceItem 6(a)Life - Term Quote & RidersCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Over-highlighting certain information· PARK
Action: Default all riders unchecked; show each rider's benefit, cost and waiting period before opt-in.
Owner: Life Digital - Pod L·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-502Basket SneakingItem 2 (chapeau)Life - Proposal & PaymentCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Adding unconsented items/charges at checkout· BLOCK
Action: Remove auto-injected cross-sell; any health cross-sell requires a separate, disclosed opt-in.
Owner: Life Digital - Pod L·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-506Subscription TrapItem 5(i)Life - Surrender & Free-lookCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Cancellation impossible or complex/lengthy· BLOCK
Action: Enable online free-look exit and surrender request; disclose the process and surrender value at purchase.
Owner: Life Servicing·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-401Subscription TrapItem 5(iv)Cancellation & Free-lookCriticalOpen
Sub-rule: Ambiguous/latent/confusing/cumbersome cancellation instructions· PARK
Action: Provide one-click online cancellation + free-look exit; disclose at purchase.
Owner: Servicing·Target: 15 Jul 2026
F-103Confirm ShamingItem 3 (chapeau)Motor - Quote & Add-onsHighRemediating
Sub-rule: Using fear/shame/ridicule/guilt to nudge a purchase or retention· BLOCK
Action: Replace with neutral copy: “Continue without Zero Depreciation”.
Owner: Motor Digital - Pod A·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-104False UrgencyItem 1 (chapeau)Motor - Quote & Add-onsHighOpen
Sub-rule: Falsely implying urgency or scarcity to force an immediate decision· BLOCK
Action: Remove non-genuine timers/scarcity; any dated offer must reference a real tariff.
Owner: Growth - Performance·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-203Confirm ShamingItem 3 (chapeau)Health - Plan & RidersHighOpen
Sub-rule: Using fear/shame/ridicule/guilt to nudge a purchase or retention· BLOCK
Action: Neutral decline copy with equal visual weight to accept.
Owner: Health Digital - Pod C·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-205Drip PricingItem 8(i)Health - Checkout & PaymentHighRemediating
Sub-rule: Price elements not revealed upfront / revealed surreptitiously· BLOCK
Action: All-inclusive payable from the plan card; itemise GST and each add-on.
Owner: Health Digital - Pod C·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-503Bait and SwitchItem 7 (chapeau)Life - Term Quote & RidersHighOpen
Sub-rule: Advertise one outcome, deliver a different one· BLOCK
Action: Headline benefit must carry the material conditions; avoid presenting conditional cover as guaranteed.
Owner: Life Product·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-504Drip PricingItem 8(i)Life - Proposal & PaymentHighRemediating
Sub-rule: Price elements not revealed upfront / revealed surreptitiously· BLOCK
Action: Show all-inclusive annual & total-term payable on the quote card; itemise GST and each rider.
Owner: Life Digital - Pod L·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-505Confirm ShamingItem 3 (chapeau)Life - Term Quote & RidersHighOpen
Sub-rule: Using fear/shame/ridicule/guilt to nudge a purchase or retention· BLOCK
Action: Neutral decline copy with equal visual weight to accept.
Owner: Life Digital - Pod L·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-301Disguised AdvertisementItem 9 (chapeau)Aggregator - Best Plans RankingHighOpen
Sub-rule: Masking ads as organic content· PARK
Action: Label paid placements; publish ranking methodology.
Owner: Aggregator Partnerships·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-302Rogue Malware / ScarewareItem 13 (chapeau)Renewal Reminder JourneyHighOpen
Sub-rule: Scareware / fake malware-removal upsell· MONITOR
Action: Lapse/penalty statements must be factual and traceable to the actual policy record.
Owner: Retention·Target: 31 Jul 2026
F-106SaaS BillingItem 12 (chapeau)Motor - Checkout & PaymentMediumOpen
Sub-rule: Surreptitious recurring billing· PARK
Action: Default auto-debit off; capture a separate, explicit recurring-mandate consent.
Owner: Payments·Target: 31 Aug 2026
F-303NaggingItem 10 (chapeau)Renewal Reminder JourneyMediumOpen
Sub-rule: Repeated, persistent prompts to force a transaction· PARK
Action: Honour declines for the session; cap re-prompts.
Owner: Retention·Target: 31 Aug 2026

5Ongoing evidence of consent

For every digital sale, the consent provenance ledger captures, in a tamper-evident hash chain: the disclosures shown and when; each cover selected or declined by the customer; the exact all-inclusive price displayed; and the final consent. This produces a non-repudiable, per-policy answer to “show me exactly what this customer was shown and how consent was obtained.”

Prepared by
Compliance Workspace
Lumen · Dark-Pattern Programme
Attested by
Principal Compliance Officer
For and on behalf of the regulated entity